Articles

How AI is changing what PE investors look for in a CFO

  • Private Equity

The Essenta View

As agentic AI moves from experimentation into everyday operations, private equity investors are having to reconsider what they need from their CFOs.

Financial discipline, commercial judgement and a record of delivering results remain essential. But investors increasingly need finance leaders with a tech-forward mindset: people who can evaluate unfamiliar opportunities, take calculated risks and adapt as the technology develops.

Among the larger PE investors, the shift is already beginning to influence CFO hiring decisions, although expectations are evolving at different speeds across funds and markets.

This shift is supported by Consero’s 2026 CFO Survey, which found that 42% of finance leaders at PE and VC-backed businesses reported that AI was broadly or fully embedded in their financial functions, up from 22% in 2025.

For investors and CEOs, the question is whether the traditional CFO hiring brief adequately reflects the demands of agentic transformation. 

Financial discipline now requires a willingness to experiment

The CFO has traditionally been the cautious custodian of a PE investor’s capital, challenging spending and maintaining financial control. Those instincts remain valuable, but AI is creating decisions for which there is little established precedent.

Investment in AI is moving from discretionary experimentation into formal budgets, with greater scrutiny of costs and measurable returns. Finance leaders must assess whether spending on automation and computing power can deliver better results than additional headcount, rather than assuming the business can afford both.

The financial implications are already becoming clear. In November 2026, Bloomberg reported that Apple had reduced daily AI spending allowances for some engineers from $300 to $200, even as it sought to expand AI adoption across its operations. The decision illustrates the challenge facing finance leaders: encouraging the use of technology that could improve productivity while keeping costs under control and ensuring the investment delivers a return.

Compliance presents another challenge. Purchasing an enterprise AI licence does not automatically resolve questions around data governance, regulatory obligations or where information is processed and stored. Businesses operating across European markets must understand how data moves between providers and whether their arrangements meet the relevant requirements. The Information Commissioner’s Office makes clear that organizations remain responsible for data protection compliance when using third-party AI systems.

These decisions increasingly involve finance. Deloitte’s Finance Trends 2027 found that 54% of surveyed finance leaders were leading enterprise AI and technology capital allocation decisions, while 48% oversaw AI and technology spending and cost controls.

The CFO must understand enough about the technology to challenge investment proposals, test the economics and establish appropriate controls. That requires curiosity and a willingness to experiment within the finance function itself.

The CFO still needs to be the person asking the difficult questions about risk, cost and return. But increasingly, they also need to be asking where the business could benefit from doing things differently. The challenge is finding someone who brings both instincts to the role with a need to learn fast but also fail fast. These attributes don’t necessarily come naturally to individuals in a function that is inherently risk adverse.



Nick Gribbon, Essenta Senior Partner, Financial Officers

Is the traditional PE CFO profile still enough?

Previous PE experience, deep sector knowledge and successful exits have long carried weight in CFO recruitment. These credentials demonstrate an ability to work with investors, operate under pressure and deliver against a value creation plan.

They remain important, but offer a less complete picture of how someone will perform when the operating model itself is changing. This is exacerbated by the fact that we are in a market where exits have been more challenging through no fault of the CFOs at the helm.

A CFO with several successful exits may have little experience of technology-led transformation. Another candidate, perhaps from an adjacent sector or outside private equity, may have demonstrated greater adaptability, experience implementing automation and an ability to make decisions in unfamiliar circumstances.

Investors may therefore need to broaden their search criteria, particularly when agentic transformation is central to the investment thesis.

The implications extend well beyond technology businesses. As AI changes how organizations manage operations, allocate resources and deliver services, CFOs across sectors will need to understand its commercial potential. Those unwilling to develop that understanding risk becoming less relevant to the businesses they lead.

A track record of successful exits tells you a great deal about a CFO’s ability to deliver against an established playbook. What it doesn’t necessarily tell you is how they’ll respond when that playbook no longer applies. I think investors need to place more weight on curiosity, adaptability and the ability to make sound decisions in unfamiliar and ambiguous territory.

Nick Gribbon, Essenta Senior Partner, Financial Officers

How do we assess a CFO for what comes next?

A candidate’s experience and track record are relatively straightforward to establish. Their ability to lead through an unfamiliar operating model requires a deeper focus on mindset and behaviours.Investors need to look beyond what candidates have achieved and examine how they approach problems they have not encountered before.

Have they experimented with AI within their own finance function? How did they evaluate the potential returns? What happened when an initiative failed to meet expectations? Were they willing to challenge their assumptions and change course?

Practical scenarios can also help. Consider a portfolio company proposing a substantial investment in agentic AI, promising lower costs and faster processes but with uncertain implementation requirements.

What would the candidate need to know before committing capital? How would they test the projected returns? What governance and compliance safeguards would they require? And what evidence would persuade them to proceed, scale back or stop?

The answers offer insight into commercial judgement, appetite for ambiguity and the ability to balance opportunity with risk.

Agentic AI is stretching the CFO role beyond financial stewardship. Leading this transformation demands an enterprise mindset, resilience and the judgement to balance innovation with financial control. Previous experience alone cannot tell us how a CFO will respond to these unfamiliar challenges. Assessment and management due diligence help reveal a candidate’s adaptability, decision-making and ability to lead through change, identifying potential pressure points that a traditional search process may miss.



Natalya Sverjensky, Essenta Partner, Leadership Advisory

This is where a combination of Executive Search and Leadership Advisory can provide a fuller picture. At Essenta, evaluating both a candidate’s track record and the behaviours that influence future performance helps investors assess their suitability for a changing CFO remit.

The CFO brief needs to reflect the future business

The right profile will depend on the investment thesis. A company beginning to explore AI will have different requirements from one undertaking a fundamental transformation of its operating model.

Few CFOs will have direct experience of everything agentic AI may bring. What matters is whether they have the financial judgement, curiosity and adaptability to navigate unfamiliar decisions while maintaining control.

Investors who continue to rely too heavily on traditional hiring criteria risk overlooking candidates better equipped for the next stage of value creation.

The question is whether the CFO hiring brief reflects the business investors intend to build, or the one they have built before.

If agentic AI is changing what your portfolio business needs from its finance leadership, start a conversation with Essenta about how to shape the CFO brief and assess candidates for what comes next.

Talk to an Essenta expert today.