Articles

Hiring for a turnaround: don’t confuse the rescue with the rebuild

  • Integrated

The Essenta View

According to EY-Parthenon, UK-listed companies issued 65 profit warnings in the third quarter of 2026, the highest quarterly total in almost two years. Some 17% of listed companies had warned at least once in the preceding 12 months.

When a business is in trouble, replacing the chief executive is a common and highly visible response. But the pressure to act quickly can lead boards to make an appointment before they have established what the business needs.

For chairs, non-executive directors and private equity investors, the challenge is to protect value while keeping the longer-term business plan achievable. That means considering two leadership questions from the outset: who can stabilize the business now, and who can lead its recovery? One person may be right for both, but success in the immediate crisis should not determine the permanent appointment by default.

Start with the diagnosis

A change of CEO only helps if the replacement is suited to the problems facing the business. Chen and Hambrick found that struggling companies recovered more effectively when poorly suited CEOs were replaced by leaders better matched to their circumstances. Boards therefore need to establish what is driving the decline before deciding who should lead the response.

Some pressures originate outside the business. EY-Parthenon reported that 54% of UK profit warnings in the third quarter of 2026 cited policy changes or geopolitical uncertainty. A new CEO cannot reverse a tariff. But boards can address a failing strategy, poor execution or weak financial management.

The response should follow the diagnosis. A failing strategy may require a new CEO. A cash crisis or deteriorating lender relationships may call for a stronger CFO or restructuring expertise at board level. A capable team facing an external shock may need support and a clearer mandate.

Before making changes, boards need an independent view of where the problems lie. That means assessing individual capabilities, how effectively the leadership team works together and whether it can deliver the recovery plan. For example, Essenta’s Leadership Advisory approach brings assessment and management due diligence into these decisions, helping establish where existing leaders can deliver, where immediate expertise is needed and which roles require permanent change.

This assessment should also shape any hiring brief. Research into CEO candidates for private equity-backed businesses found that subsequent performance was more strongly associated with execution skills than interpersonal skills. Boards should examine what candidates have delivered in comparable situations, the decisions they made and whether they achieved their targets.

Rescue and rebuild ask different things

Stabilization may involve controlling cash, reducing costs and negotiating with lenders. Recovery brings different priorities: restoring performance, developing a credible growth strategy and rebuilding confidence. Decisions made during the rescue can either support or constrain what comes next.

Rosabeth Moss Kanter, drawing on nearly two dozen turnarounds, found that financial measures alone were insufficient for lasting recovery. Leaders also had to restore people’s confidence and their ability to work together.

An executive who excels at restructuring may be less effective at building an organization for growth. Others can manage both. In a study of four turnarounds, O’Kane and Cunningham found that effective leaders were distinguished by their ability to balance competing demands, rather than by a particular leadership type.

Boards should assess leadership against the full recovery plan. Cost reductions may be essential, but cutting too deeply into the capabilities needed for growth can undermine the value the turnaround is intended to protect. The leader responsible for the rescue needs to understand those consequences, even if someone else will lead the next phase.

The right approach may be one CEO for both stages, an Interim followed by a permanent appointment, or targeted support for the existing team.

When does a business need an Interim CEO?

An Interim CEO can be valuable when action cannot wait but the board has yet to establish its permanent leadership requirements. Cash may need stabilizing, lenders may need reassurance or a restructuring plan may need implementing. In the Institute of Interim Management’s 2026 survey, 13% of respondents’ most recent assignments involved turnaround or restructuring.

An experienced Interim can make difficult decisions quickly, challenge established assumptions and draw on experience of similar situations. Their appointment also gives the board time to establish what the business needs from its permanent leadership.

The role should reflect the problem. Where the business needs an immediate change of leadership, an Interim CEO may be appropriate. Where the pressure is concentrated in finance or restructuring, an Interim CFO or restructuring director may have greater impact while the existing CEO remains in place.

Whatever the appointment, the board must agree to a clear mandate before the Interim starts. This should specify the outcomes required, the deadlines and the authority to act without further approval. Priorities might include stabilizing cash flow, reaching agreement with lenders, improving financial reporting or implementing cost reductions.

The board should also define what the Interim needs to leave behind. Clear handover objectives help protect the progress made during the rescue and prepare the business for its next leader.

Plan the permanent appointment early

Waiting until the crisis has passed to begin the permanent search creates another deadline. Research by Langan and Deuschel suggests that, although Interim CEO successions can be disruptive, the Interim period can help boards select a better-fitting permanent successor when the appointment is particularly difficult.

The permanent search should begin while the rescue is under way. As the business stabilizes, the board will learn more about its underlying problems, the capabilities within the team and what the next leader must deliver. Those findings should inform the search brief.

An Interim who has stabilized the business may be a strong candidate, but should face the same assessment as anyone else. Can they develop a sustainable strategy, build an effective management team and restore confidence among employees, customers and investors? Their performance during the rescue provides valuable evidence. The board still needs to establish whether they can deliver the next stage.

For private equity investors, that means assessing candidates against the value creation plan as well as immediate turnaround priorities. Chairs and NEDs must also consider whether the appointment provides the leadership capability and stability the business will need over the longer term.

Starting early gives the board time to compare candidates properly and make the permanent appointment without the pressure of another leadership deadline.

One plan for both phases

A turnaround puts enormous pressure on leadership decisions. The board needs to act quickly, but the choices made during the rescue will shape the business’s prospects long after the immediate crisis has passed.

Our view is that leadership assessment, immediate support and permanent succession should form part of the same plan. Each decision should build on what has been learned about the business, with the focus firmly on protecting value, maintaining momentum and delivering the recovery.

This is the thinking behind Essenta’s integrated approach. Leadership Advisory provides an objective assessment of capability and gaps. Interim brings experienced executives into the business when action cannot wait, while Executive Search identifies permanent leaders equipped to deliver the next stage. Connecting these disciplines allows boards to address immediate leadership needs while planning for the recovery ahead.